What to Post and What to Avoid in Gaming Subreddits

9 December 2025

If you've ever wandered into a gaming subreddit, you've probably noticed it can be a wild, magical, and sometimes unpredictable world. Whether you're a casual gamer, a hardcore completionist, or an aspiring game dev, Reddit is one of the few places where passionate communities gather to share thoughts, guide noobs, and sometimes just meme the heck out of their favorite titles.

But here's the thing: not everything flies in every subreddit. Post the wrong thing, and you might find your karma tanking faster than your KD ratio in a ranked match. So, if you want to thrive in gaming subreddits—and, more importantly, not get yourself banned—we've got some do’s and don’ts to go over.

Let’s dive right in.

Why Gaming Subreddits Are a Big Deal

Gaming subreddits are more than just forums—they're hangouts, news hubs, and support groups all rolled into one pixelated package. From r/gaming and r/pcgaming to niche subs like r/stardewvalley or r/eldenring, these spaces can be goldmines for advice, entertainment, and connection.

But they're also moderated heavily to prevent spam, low-effort content, and toxic behavior. Understanding what to post and what to avoid can make or break your experience in these communities.

What You SHOULD Post in Gaming Subreddits

Let’s start with the good stuff—the kind of posts that spark discussions, rake in upvotes, and maybe even get you a Reddit Gold or two.

1. High-Quality Screenshots and Gameplay Clips

If you just pulled off a 1v4 clutch in CS:GO or built a Skyrim mod that turns dragons into Thomas the Tank Engine (classic), by all means—share it. But here’s the catch: quality matters. Nobody’s going to upvote a blurry, low-res shot of your character standing still.

👉 Use proper formatting, give your post a clear title, and make sure what you're posting actually "says" something. Is it impressive? Funny? Emotional? Memeworthy?

2. Helpful Guides and Tips

Gamers love sharing knowledge almost as much as they love arguing about frame rates. Whether it's a Dark Souls boss guide or a quick XP farm hack in Genshin Impact, useful tips are pure Reddit gold.

⚠️ Just make sure your guide is readable and formatted nicely. Bullet points are your friend. Nobody wants to scroll through a wall of text while dodging skeleton warriors.

3. Meaningful Discussions and Questions

Have a hot take on loot boxes? Got thoughts about the future of AAA games? Ask away or share your perspective. Gaming subreddits thrive on thoughtful conversations. Just be ready to back up your opinion—Redditors don’t mess around.

💡 Pro tip: Phrase your question in a way that invites answers. Instead of "Why is this game so bad?" try "What are your thoughts on the game's combat mechanics?"

4. Fan Art and Creative Projects

Artists and creators—your time to shine! Posting your custom designs, cosplay progress, or even that chiptune remix of the Halo theme is a great way to connect with like-minded folks. Just remember to tag it properly and avoid self-promotion (more on that later).

🎨 If it’s original and passion-filled, people will notice.

5. News and Relevant Updates

Stay up to date with upcoming patches, dev updates, or delays? Sharing timely news (from legitimate sources, please) can be super helpful, especially in smaller or game-specific subreddits.

📰 Just don’t copy/paste an entire article—summarize it and link back to the source.

6. Community Involvement Posts

Sometimes, it's not about the game—it’s about the players. Sharing funny in-game moments, asking about others’ favorite characters, or starting a “Let’s see your loadouts!” thread can really bring the community together.

💬 These posts make you part of the crew, not just another name in the feed.

What to AVOID Posting in Gaming Subreddits

Reddit isn't the Wild West—there are rules. And mods actually enforce them.

Let’s break down the types of posts that tend to get nuked, downvoted into oblivion, or worse—earn you a boot.

1. Low-Effort Content or Spam

Posting a blurry screenshot saying “Look at this!” or sharing a link with zero context is a no-go. Reddit loves effort. If it seems like you didn’t care, you’ll get the same energy back.

🚫 Think of it this way: if your post looks like it took less time to write than it takes to boot up your console, it’s probably low effort.

2. Reposts and Recycled Memes

Reddit has a memory like an elephant—and a search bar. Reposting old memes or screenshots already seen a hundred times brings nothing new to the table.

📉 Use platforms like KarmaDecay to check if your post already made the rounds.

3. Self-Promotion Without Engagement

Sharing your YouTube Let's Play or Twitch channel? Tread carefully. Most gaming subs are very strict about self-promo. If you're just dropping links without being part of the discussion, mods will probably deep-six your post in seconds.

📌 Read the sub rules. Some allow self-promo on certain days or in pinned threads. Otherwise, earn respect before you advertise.

4. Off-Topic Posts

Posting about politics in r/halo or your cat’s birthday in r/witcher? Yeah… no. Keep it relevant. Even if it loosely ties into gaming ("My cat steps on my controller—LOL"), it might still get removed.

🎮 When in doubt, ask yourself: Is this actually about the game or community?

5. Toxic Behavior or Flamebait

It goes without saying, but let’s say it anyway: being toxic, starting console wars, or attacking other users is a one-way ticket to Banville. Subreddits want passionate discussions—not raging arguments.

🔥 Even if you strongly disagree, stay respectful. No one wins a flame war, except maybe the mods with their banhammers.

6. Clickbait Titles and Misleading Thumbnails

Trying to trick users into clicking your post with titles like “You won’t believe what happened…” or using dramatic thumbnails? Reddit doesn't work like YouTube. Clickbait just annoys people and damages your credibility.

🧂 Keep it honest. If it’s worth clicking, the content will speak for itself.

Bonus Tips to Up Your Reddit Game

Let’s sprinkle in a few extra tips to help you become a true Redditor—not just a lurker.

✅ Read the Sidebar

Every subreddit has its own set of rules, usually tucked in the right-hand sidebar. They’re not there for decoration. Read 'em. Follow 'em.

✅ Use Descriptive Titles

Instead of “Check this out,” go with “Insane 200m sniper shot in Battlefield 2042.” The more descriptive your title, the better chance of catching interest.

✅ Engage With Comments

Don’t just post and vanish. Stick around. Thank people for feedback, answer questions, and get involved. It shows you're not just there for karma points.

✅ Be Consistent, Not Spammy

Regular contributors tend to earn trust over time. But posting 10 times a day? That just feels spammy. Think quality over quantity.

✅ Know the Culture

Lurk before you leap. Spend some time scrolling through the top posts. See what works and what doesn’t. Each subreddit has its own vibe—some love memes, others love deep dives.

Final Thoughts

Gaming subreddits are like gaming lounges. Some are wild and loud, others are quiet and nerdy, but all of them have their own rhythm. If you respect the vibe, bring something of value to the table, and stay cool even when the comment section heats up—you'll be just fine.

So next time you're about to hit that "post" button, pause and ask yourself: Is this something I'd want to see if I were scrolling? If the answer is yes, fire away.

Happy posting, and may your upvotes be plentiful!