5 Best Video Games Like The Quarry

July 24, 2026 - 10:20

If you finished "The Quarry" and want more interactive horror stories where your choices actually matter, there are several games that scratch that same itch. These titles focus on branching narratives, tough moral decisions, and cinematic presentation.

First on the list is "Until Dawn," the spiritual predecessor from the same developer. Set on a snowy mountain, it follows eight friends trapped by a killer and something far worse. The quick-time events and butterfly effect system feel very familiar, but the tone leans more into slasher movie tropes.

Another strong pick is "Dark Pictures Anthology: Man of Medan." This is a shorter, more replayable experience about a ghost ship. It works well for co-op play, letting you pass the controller or play online. The scares rely on atmosphere and jump moments rather than character depth.

For something with more action, try "The Walking Dead" by Telltale Games. While it uses a comic book art style instead of realistic graphics, the emotional weight of your choices is massive. You will care deeply about the characters, especially Clementine. The story spans multiple seasons, giving you plenty of time to invest.

If you want a supernatural mystery with a 1980s summer camp vibe, "The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope" is a solid choice. It deals with guilt, history, and hallucinations. The story can be confusing on a first playthrough, but the branching paths are extensive.

Finally, consider "Life is Strange." It is not a horror game, but it shares the same focus on dialogue choices and consequences. You play as a photography student who can rewind time. The emotional payoff is strong, and your decisions ripple through the entire story. It proves that interactive drama does not need monsters to be gripping.